For those of us who didn't get an instruction manual with our babies and for whom parenting hasn't always gone as planned. On a more serious note this blog is about supporting a woman's ability to make her own choices about parenting including the choice, for whatever reason, to bottle feed her babies formula.

BlogHer Ad Network
More from BlogHer
Advertise here
BlogHer Privacy Policy
Flexible Recognition

ROFL button

Best of Blog Exchange



GNM Parents Hot Stuff

Flexible Links

My Blogging Inspiration
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants

Flexible Affiliations


Parent Bloggers Network
- Crazy/Hip Blog-Mamas+
(Random Site)
A Member of Bust's Girl Wide Web
Parenting Blogs - Blog Top Sites
blog search directory
Search For Blogs, Submit Blogs, The Ultimate Blog Directory

Friday, April 18, 2008

Fine Motor Skills Finds

Thanks for all your comments and suggestions! I have found out some interesting things about fine motor skills in the past day.

First of all, I decided of course that I'm going to do the suggested activities on the worksheet from my older son's (OS) teacher. Since my younger son (YS) wants to do everything that OS does, he'll also be participating. However, since YS has always had remarkable fine motor skills, this extra work will probably give him superhero skills where at the tender age of 21 months, he'll be able unlock the deadbolt go outside and hotwire my car.

I talked to a friend of mine who was a kindergarten teacher for many years and she told me something very interesting. She said contrary to what people might think, many times the best way to work on fine motor skills is to work on the upper arm strength. Of course I should have OS do the activities for fine motor skills, but I should alternate them with upper arm strength skills; one day for fine motor skills and one day for doing things like throwing a ball.

The reason behind this is that if the upper arms aren't strong enough, it affects the way the entire arm functions. It doesn't go backwards though so working on fine motor skills does not increase arm strength. Too bad about that or I could trade my weight lifting for typing on my computer!

One of the questions she asked me is if OS crawled using his arms. Not surprisingly he didn't. He was a "butt hopper". I don't know how to explain because I've never seen another kid do it nor had his pediatrician, but it was like he frog hopped on his bottom. He would actually get clearance. My friend said that he may have never fully developed his arm strength.

Then she told me the big question. Get ready because here it is: can your child do the monkey bars? Yes, you did read that right. There is a correlation between kids doing monkey bars and penmanship. The better the kids are at the monkey bars, the better the penmanship. The Big Giraffe looked stunned by this realization because he really struggled with monkey bars as a kid and he still struggles with his penmanship now. It all has to do with arm strength. Needless to say, OS cannot hold on for more than a second or two much less attempt to move to the next bar.

We actually had already been discussing enrolling OS in gymnastics. He's currently in swimming and I didn't want to do too much. However, school is over next month so I think two activities for the summer would be really fun for him. Actually for all my initial issues with art class, I soon began swim team and did gymnastics and I would go so far as to say the fine motor skills are one of my strengths now. In the meantime, we will be doing fun and exciting things like picking up pasta and dried beans with tongs and working on monkey bars at the park. I have a feeling the Big Giraffe will be right behind OS in line for the monkey bars.

I talked to OS's teacher this morning and she said that OS's struggle is age appropriate. Phew! Other kids in the class also got the note.

A. Elliot's Lesson Learned: Got bad penmanship? Go for a swing or two across the monkey bars.

Labels: ,

posted by Alex Elliot @ 8:46 AM   5 comments
5 Comments:
  • At 4/18/2008 10:54 AM, Blogger Goofball said…

    what are Monkey Bars????????

     
  • At 4/18/2008 11:40 AM, Blogger Whirlwind said…

    I'm surprised with the monkey bars! most kids in my daughter's first grade class are just starting to be able to do the monkey bars! And I never could, but have fairly decent hand writting. My oldest cannot move from bar to bar, but she can hang forever. We got them a jungle gym with bars so they'll probably get plenty of practice this summer!

    My best friends daughter was a butt hopper! It was very weird and I never saw anyone else do it.

     
  • At 4/18/2008 11:57 AM, Blogger Heather said…

    Hmmm. That's really interesting stuff.

    My daughter was an Army crawler. She'd pull herself along with just her arms. It was quite a feat. I think she transitioned to hands and knees for a week or two before she just stood up and walked.

    My son looked a little like a frog.

    I think it's actually really cool to see the different methods babies come up with to get moving.

    I'll have to ask my hubs if he was good at Monkey bars because his handwriting is atrocious.

     
  • At 4/18/2008 2:36 PM, Blogger Suzanne said…

    Actually, I have excellent, beautiful, flowing penmanship but I have never, ever been able to go across the monkeybars. (Goofball, mokeybars are a tall play structure in which kids swing with their arms from one rung to the next to get across.) My upper arm strength is basically non-existent. I can do calligraphy, though, so I guess there is an exception to every rule.

    On a semi-related note, it always cracks me up when people tell me that I have beautiful handwriting. Is that not a bizarre compliment?

     
  • At 4/18/2008 4:11 PM, Blogger Alex Elliot said…

    It is just a correlation. It has to do with upper arm strength so it's how long you can hold yourself not necessarily how far you can go across. However, I think her point is that most kids would probably not just hang there if they could go on to the next bar. I'm sure it's largely dependent on how often you go on the monkey bars therefore someone who's at the park every day and struggles with the monkey bars vs. someone who's at the park every day and can go across.

    Whirlwind, I was surprised by that to but I do have to say I've also been surprised by the number of kids OS's age who can do one or two bars.

     
Post a Comment
Home
 
Wednesday, April 16, 2008

I Am Not My Child-Repeat After Me

This morning at playgroup I asked one of the moms who is a teacher about bullying. This has been a topic on our moms group list-serve and I was surprised that no one had suggested talking with the parents to handle the situation. I wasn't sure if you weren't supposed to do that or if I had missed an email where the mom explained that either she already had talked to the other mom or had chosen not to for a specific reason. Turns out it was the latter. However, my friend did say that a lot of times parents don't want to hear that their child is being a bully.

You probably know where this one is going. Immediately I swore to myself that I was never going be one of "those" parents who didn't want to hear that her child was less than perfect. I mentally scoffed at those parents. Then I went to pick up my older son (OS) from preschool.

After unclipping his backpack and strapping him into his booster seat, I opened up his backpack and noticed a note from his teacher. It contained a printed list of things to do to improve fine motor skills. At the top was a sentence from the teacher suggesting that OS do some of them. I felt myself getting defensive. OS didn't have a problem with his fine motor skills! His skills are just fine. He's four not fourteen! There's no reason that being a little behind in fine motor skills should cause someone to almost fail art class and thus be in danger of repeating second grade. Oh wait a minute, that was me! Who exactly was I talking about? I silently said my little mantra "I am not my child, my child is not me".

I still felt a little indignant. Then I remembered that only seconds earlier I had found myself questioning whether OS may have a little difficulty with fine motor skills. After all, he cannot strap himself into his booster seat with his seatbelt, and he cannot easily clip the straps of his backpack across his chest, much less unclip them. While his teacher had mentioned to me that she still has to help some of the kids in the class, most of them can do these things themselves. OS is one of the youngest in the class...though. Hmm...apparently I just can't get past this art class. It probably is a good idea to do some Crafts for the Clueless-worthy activities follow some of the suggestions from the worksheet. Of course I left a message for the teacher to to discuss it.

A. Elliot's Lesson Learned: You are not your child-repeat after me.

Labels:

posted by Alex Elliot @ 8:55 PM   9 comments
9 Comments:
  • At 4/16/2008 9:39 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    The magazines that both boys get monthly, probably have activities that would be of benefit.

     
  • At 4/17/2008 7:52 AM, Blogger Goofball said…

    I'm sure every parent struggles with taking comments regarding their child too personal. It's good that you try to be aware of that.

     
  • At 4/17/2008 9:24 AM, Blogger Heather said…

    I can identify with this. I get all defensive when given suggestions of what to do to help my kids. I don't know why I take it that way. I suppose I'm thinking it's a reflection of me.

    Good mantra...I think I need to start repeating that to myself.

     
  • At 4/17/2008 9:49 AM, Blogger Fairly Odd Mother said…

    Great message to remember.

     
  • At 4/17/2008 1:31 PM, Blogger Jen of A2eatwrite said…

    Hey Alex... You aren't your child, but the small motor thing can have genetic components. It's not a big deal for OS, but if he doesn't balk at trying the exercises, why not? OTOH, sometimes preschool teachers forget differences between boys and girls - and there's no doubt the girls trump the boys (generally speaking) in small motor skills in that age group.

     
  • At 4/17/2008 5:30 PM, Blogger Worker Mommy said…

    It's hard not to be initially defensive. I mean it is your baby after all. I think many of us have the inclination to get defensive when we receive criticisms about our children. We want to believe that our children are truly perfect. (or that we are the only ones who can point out their shortcomings)

     
  • At 4/17/2008 9:28 PM, OpenID cablegirl said…

    So I have this great book at Jen of a2eatwrite suggested to me that has activities for kids 0-5. Email me and I'll send you some descriptions of motor skills building games for OS's age range.:)

     
  • At 4/17/2008 9:36 PM, Blogger Suzanne said…

    Damn, you are hilarious.

     
  • At 4/18/2008 8:35 AM, Blogger painted maypole said…

    a lesson i often have to relearn. ;)

     
Post a Comment
Home
 
Monday, March 24, 2008

The Dreaded Phone Call

As soon as I found out I was pregnant, I realized that there were a number of phone calls I never wanted to receive. Some of them are obvious like a phone call from the hospital. Some of them came to me the longer I have been a mom. Unfortunately today I received one such phone call from the director of my older son's (OS) preschool. Immediately visions of what it could be flashed through my mind:
  • a broken arm, no the director wouldn't sound so cheerful
  • OS had told his entire class how babies were made, that seemed very likely
  • OS had pushed someone, unlikely as he's not very aggressive, but then again you never know
  • OS had peed in his pants or worse, again not likely
  • OS had said said a swear word, no comment on that one except to say that I have never heard him say a swear word and the Big Giraffe and I do try to watch what we say
  • Oh no, I knew what it was! He had that stomach bug that was going around his preschool
It turns out it was none of those things. It was Pink Eye! Yeah, I was thrilled, particularly when the director said it was likely that our younger son (YS) would get it along with the Big Giraffe and me. I think I would rather have the stomach bug. Of course I felt bad that I had brought OS to school and exposed the whole class. Honestly, if I had thought he had it, I obviously would not have sent him. I do have to say that I am pleased that we've gone this long without every experiencing pink eye. In fact, this is the first of the common childhood illnesses that either of my kids have had. We've, knock on wood big time, have not yet experienced strep throat, Fifth's Disease or Hand Foot and Mouth. Hopefully I won't be getting phone calls about that in the few weeks. Now I just have to make sure to check caller ID to screen out any angry calls from parents of OS's classmates!

A. Elliot's Lesson Learned: Eventually Pink Eye does seem to hit every family.

Labels: ,

posted by Alex Elliot @ 9:13 AM   12 comments
12 Comments:
  • At 3/24/2008 10:08 AM, OpenID cablegirl said…

    you do really like to tempt Murphy, don't you. ;)

    Here's to hoping you don't all end up itchy and sore at the same time.

     
  • At 3/24/2008 10:59 AM, Blogger Whirlwind said…

    Words of advice - if you get a prescription - ask for the drops instead of the cream stuff -it's much easier!

    And I wouldn't wish Hand Foot and Mouth on anyone. Absolutely the worst (I'm a bit biased though, because my daughter came down with a secondary potentially life threatening disease as a side effect from the aforementioned disease)

     
  • At 3/24/2008 1:02 PM, Blogger Jen of A2eatwrite said…

    Ooooo.... I agree with Whirlwind. Glad it's "only" pink eye. Hope you're all well soon!

     
  • At 3/24/2008 1:57 PM, Blogger Heather said…

    Yeah, I'd take pinkeye over some of the other stuff I guess!

     
  • At 3/24/2008 2:42 PM, Blogger Worker Mommy said…

    Ah, man, I'm sorry. It hit our house when the twins were 2. It is soooo hard to put eyedrops in a two year olds eye.

    Hope y'all get past this soon!

     
  • At 3/24/2008 2:49 PM, Blogger PinksandBluesGirls said…

    Oh, no! My entire family just recovered from the pink eye plague... first my 3-year old grandson, then his 1-year old brother, then my daughter (their mommy), and of course me because I was taking care of them all! Add to that coughs, sore throats... you name it. I agree with whirlwind to get the drops.

    I've washed my hands 'til my skin is raw and gone though a dozen rolls of paper towels... but it seems the worst is over!

    I'll be thinking of you,
    Sharon - Pinks & Blues

     
  • At 3/24/2008 7:56 PM, Anonymous selfmademom.net said…

    I just hope you don't end up with pink eye! wash your hands... I get pink eye at least twice a year- not fun.

     
  • At 3/24/2008 8:03 PM, Blogger soccer mom in denial said…

    The SECOND your eye feels yucky, get the drops or ointment. I was able to avoid the guck and redness this last go around.

    Oh and those dreaded phone calls? My favorite was the first day of school last year and I got a call at 2:30 asking where I was. I thought school went until 3pm. They got out at 2:20pm.

     
  • At 3/24/2008 8:32 PM, OpenID pincushionpoints said…

    I am so sorry you are dealing with the pink crud. There was a bad outbreak in Oregon a couple of months ago and both my girls got it more than once. Luckily it was just the girls and J and I both avoided it.

    The nurse recommended Clorox bleach wipes - those things are fantastic. I'm sure you already know, but you should bleach everything in sight to kill the germ.

     
  • At 3/24/2008 11:09 PM, Blogger Kami said…

    Oh no! I have had pink eye and it isn't fun. Thankfully the boys have avoided that thus far.

    We have not been so lucky with Rotavirus though. I think I'd take pink eye. Want to trade?

    ;-)

     
  • At 3/25/2008 9:57 PM, Blogger Mandy said…

    we just got thru our round of pink eye .... I got it worse then my 3 year old ... NOT FUN!!

     
  • At 3/27/2008 9:51 PM, Blogger Suzanne said…

    Ah, pink eye. Just thinking about it makes my eyes watery. Or maybe it's all the damn rabbit fur that's flying around my apartment...

     
Post a Comment
Home
 
Wednesday, March 19, 2008

My Brand of Education: One Child Left Behind

Faithful readers of this blog are familiar with Lindsey. She is the woman who saved helped me when I had that monstrous teeny tiny mishap - accidentally locking my clothes in a locker with a random lock that happened to be hanging there while only wearing a towel. Last week her 5th grade math class was working on different number combinations, using locks as an example. The class apparently did so well that she decided to reward them with a humorous story about locks. Yes, that would be the story about yours truly. It was an example of how the right combination does you no good if it isn't applied to the correct lock. The class thought it was hilarious. Just glad to be doing my part to educate today's youth. Alright, I even admit it was really funny...in retrospect...alright it was even funny when it was happening!

Not every child enjoyed a recent brush with the education system. As I predicted on Monday, my younger son (YS) did pitch a fit today when I dropped my older son (OS) off at preschool. I assumed he believed that his brother was being feted with cookies and brownies at preschool. However, when I took him out of his carseat at home, I realized he had been uncomfortable from sitting on a Fisher Price Little People dog. He was all smiles once he was back to playing with OS's most coveted toys while his brother was at school.

A. Elliot's Lesson Learned: Playing at home and hearing stories at school are both fun.

Labels: , ,

posted by Alex Elliot @ 6:08 PM   8 comments
8 Comments:
  • At 3/19/2008 9:14 PM, Blogger Jodi said…

    That reminds me of when Michael complained his feet hurt so we took him to get his shoes checked and it turned out he had a rock in his shoe. Yeah, we are morons.

     
  • At 3/19/2008 9:38 PM, Blogger Heather said…

    I ignored my daughter when she was 3 and insisted she didn't feel well. I took her to preschool anyway because I thought she was just being a pill. Then she threw up all over the car.

    I learned to listen to her a little better.

    It's nice that you're an educational tool now.

     
  • At 3/19/2008 11:39 PM, Blogger Kami said…

    Hey, at least it was used for educational purposes.

    Tee hee!

     
  • At 3/19/2008 11:52 PM, Blogger Tracey said…

    Ha!

    And it's good to know that big brother's toys are still more alluring than potential cookies and juice...

     
  • At 3/20/2008 2:15 PM, Blogger Worker Mommy said…

    Hee, hee, good for you for doing your part to help further children's education ;)

     
  • At 3/20/2008 5:00 PM, Blogger Chantelle said…

    Ha ha! That is another well learned lesson. Put another way, if you child is crying, always make sure to check that they aren't sitting on anything pokey.

     
  • At 3/20/2008 6:09 PM, OpenID cablegirl said…

    Oooh... Poor YS. I feel his pain... or rather MJ feels his pain. I found a wooden car under her after a 20 minute drive where I thought she was just being argumentative.

     
  • At 3/20/2008 6:13 PM, Blogger soccer mom in denial said…

    Not fair! How do you manage to tell two hysterical stories in less than 500 words?! You are amazing.

     
Post a Comment
Home
 
Monday, March 17, 2008

Sibling Rivalry and a Window into Preschool

Throughout the year, my older son (OS) has had a number of parties at his preschool where specific parents were invited to help. I participated in his preschool birthday party at the beginning of the year, and since then I have been waiting for my invitation to return. I was thus excited when my younger son (YS) and I were invited to help out at today's preschool St. Patrick's Day party. Of course, I wasn't even half as excited as YS. While at 20 months-old, he has not asked me any questions about OS's preschool curriculum, he has become increasingly interested over the past few weeks in what happens to OS between preschool drop-off and pick-up.

When we walked into the classroom, YS found that the teacher had set aside a spot for him at one of the snack tables. He sat down and was given a shamrock plate, followed by a sprinkle cookie and then, drum roll please, a frosted brownie. These treats were topped off by a Dixie cup of apple juice. YS seemed thrilled beyond belief! I could just see the wheels turning in his head. This must be what preschool is like for OS every time! The fun didn't stop with snack time. YS joined the other students in going through books, danced to Irish music with the other students, and finally sat quietly with the other students while yours truly read a story. YS even went outside to play on the playground with the other students.

I'm curious to see if YS will want to go to preschool with OS on Wednesday. I predict a giant temper tantrum will ensue. I hope I'm wrong.

A. Elliot's Lesson Learned: Whether or not learning is fun, school is.

Labels:

posted by Alex Elliot @ 8:07 PM   6 comments
6 Comments:
Post a Comment
Home
 
Friday, March 14, 2008

Pride, Pet Rocks, and Alex Elliot: Annoying Parent

Before I became a parent, I vowed that I would never be one of those obnoxious parents that would boast about their kids left and right. You know what that's like...you politely ask a mom (or dad) how her kid is doing and she gives you a list of the kid's top 50 achievements...in the four months that have passed since his birth. I would never ever do that!

Who am I kidding? I have yet to find a pre-parent declaration that I've kept. There may, and I stress may, possibly have been some blatant subtle bragging during the past five years. I do know one thing for sure though, I just have to take a moment here to talk about how impressed I am with my older son (OS). Yes, I know I am just like am one of those annoying parents. Come on though and cut me some slack! My most recent post was about how both my kids were playing in the toilet yesterday, not how they were finding the cure for cancer.

OS is really into ocean life. Some kids are really into trains, dinosaurs or pirates for example, and they can tell you every little detail about them. That's how OS is about marine life, in particular dolphins and whales. He can recognize many sea creatures, and even explain the differences between various types of dolphins and whales.

This morning when I dropped OS off at preschool, his teacher handed me a pet rock that he made in class. She told me that most of the kids chose to do bunnies, kittens, or puppies for their pet rocks. Not OS. He made a whale pet rock. It was the only whale pet rock in the class. After school I asked OS to tell me about his whale pet rock. First he specified that it was not just any pet rock, but was specifically a blue whale pet rock. I noticed two cotton balls on the rock. OS matter of factly told me that the two cotton balls were for the two flukes of the whale's tail. Six months ago, I didn't even know what a fluke was! OS actually ensured that his whale had them.

Yes, I know I know. I'm totally bragging here, but I was just so proud that he took an interest and carried it over into a school craft. Alright now I'm off to slink away. Did I mention that my kids bathed a cloth doll in the toilet yesterday?

Whale Pet RockPicture of Blue Whale


I still can't find my camera and had to rely on my cell phone.

A. Elliot's Lesson Learned: It is no fluke that I am proud of my children.

Labels: , ,

posted by Alex Elliot @ 6:50 PM   7 comments
7 Comments:
  • At 3/14/2008 8:14 PM, OpenID cablegirl said…

    I think it is spectacular that he has a subject abotu which he is so interested that he wants to share it with not only his family but his class as well.

    You totally get bragging rights on that. :)

     
  • At 3/14/2008 8:27 PM, OpenID pincushionpoints said…

    I think you should be proud of his pet whale. I work with Fish Biologists all day long, so I am particular to sea creatures myself. What a fine whale he made. :-)

     
  • At 3/14/2008 8:50 PM, Blogger Jen of A2eatwrite said…

    He's a darling pet rock whale! And passions are wonderful. If you ever get down to NYC, go to the Museum of Natural History and to the Hall of Oceans to see the Blue Whale there - it will rock his world. That's the best museum room in the universe, as far as I'm concerned. ;-)

     
  • At 3/14/2008 9:17 PM, Blogger Heather said…

    You should be proud! That's great that he knows that stuff. My kids haven't ever gotten that interested in anything to want to learn that much about it.

     
  • At 3/15/2008 8:08 AM, Blogger Wonderful World of Weiners said…

    That is the best damn blue whale rock I've ever seen! Ok, I havent seen many but this one ranks #1~~

    Hallie

     
  • At 3/15/2008 10:25 AM, Blogger Kami said…

    Okay, so is it wrong to admit that I haven't the foggiest what a fluke is?

    So, having said that, you have every right to brag about your little marine biologist!

    And the toilet bathing, he's just honing his oceanography skills.

    Tee hee!

     
  • At 3/16/2008 4:49 AM, Blogger Chantelle said…

    That is an awesome whale. Totally bragworthy.
    I have realized lately I have a horrible habit of actaully downplaying my baby's strengths among other mothers because I am trying to compensate for the fact that deep down I think my kid is so cool. That has to be a worse habit than actually bragging, doesn't it?

     
Post a Comment
Home
 
Saturday, March 08, 2008

Homeschooling Restrictions in CA and Breastfeeding

I know, what a bizarre title! What does one thing have to do with the other? Well, yesterday I read an article in the Chicago Sun Times about breastfeeding or rather the the big push for people to breastfeed regardless of whether it's the best decision or even feasible for a particular family. It's called Moms Feel Pushed to Breastfeed. It actually was a very interesting article because it talked about the history of La Leche. La Leche was founded to ensure people have the support they need to be able to choose breastfeeding. To some people, it continues to be an invaluable support. Some perceive certain chapters as "pushing for your right to choose, but only if you choose breast-feeding." I empathized with one of the women who felt guilty about not breastfeeding.

Then I read an article about the restrictions on homeschooling in California where a state appellate court ruled that parents must have a teaching certificate in order to be homeschooled.

So what do the two articles have to do with each other? To me they're about choices. Personally, I'm not planning on homeschooling my children. I reserve the right to change my mind, but for a variety of reasons, I don't currently consider it a fit for me. However, I like that I have the choice to be able to do it. I like that I can decide what's best for my children and my family without government interference. I think there are many reasons to homeschool kids. While a teacher's certificate may ensure that parents are qualified to homeschool their children, certification does not guarantee that a parent will do a good job. More importantly, lack of certification does not mean that a parent cannot do a good job of homeschooling.

I am not convinced that homeschooling parents should be accountable to the government. On one hand, I can understand wanting to make sure that children are learning the basic skills they need. On the other hand, once the government is regulating what children learn, I struggle with where the line should be drawn. However, if we assume for the moment that California is right in believing that homeschooling parents are accountable to the government, a more fundamental question is whether requiring teaching certification is the best way to drive such accountability.

I don't think that having a teacher's certificate means that children will necessarily be homeschooled better than children whose parents do not possess the certification. Do I think there's a good chance that those kids will get a good education? Sure. But it's not a guarantee. Nor is it a guarantee that children of a parent without the certification won't have a good education. Personally, if the government should be regulating homeschooling this way, I prefer the approach that I have heard described in Massachusetts, where parents are required to go over their lesson plans with school superintendents. That way there is some sort of check. I've also been told that most MA libraries offer lesson plans that parents can use.

If MA were to try something similar to CA, I would be out picketing with all the homeschoolers. I know not all families homeschool for religious reasons, but it does seem ironic to me that liberal me would be on the same side of the picket line as some people who are very conservative.

Ultimately, parents are the ones who know themselves and their children the best. Whether it's breastfeeding or homeschooling, you're the one raising your child. Neither government experts nor community organizations are around for midnight feedings or when your child doesn't understand fractions. Our kids aren't all the same. We as parents aren't all the same. Our families are not all the same. We don't all learn the same way. We also don't handle social situations the same way. Finally we don't cook the same way. Why would we need to feed our children the same way or educate them the same way?

A. Elliot's Lesson Learned: Parents should have freedom of choice.

Labels: , ,

posted by Alex Elliot @ 7:04 PM   13 comments
13 Comments:
  • At 3/08/2008 10:10 PM, OpenID cablegirl said…

    I was outraged when I read the article about the CA decision. First of all, HS parents are accountable. They have to report yearly on the progress of students. There are state requirements that must be met. I'm not exactly sure why the supposition is that forcing parents to get teaching certs will guarantee a better education. Many, many many HSed children far surpass the level of education of their public school classmates.

    yes, if I were in CA I'd be picketing. If this becomes an issue in FL, you know I will be.

    btw, I tried to email you earlier with a response to a question you asked, but for some reason it got bounced back. Shoot me an email and I'll reply to it. :)

     
  • At 3/08/2008 10:54 PM, Blogger Heather said…

    Amen to that!

     
  • At 3/09/2008 11:18 AM, Blogger Jen of A2eatwrite said…

    CA has tons of crazy education laws for both the regular-schooled, homeschooled, etc.

    The teaching certificate thing is laughable. They already have way too many restrictions in CA.

    What I'm most worried about is its setting a precedent for laws in other states. I'm guessing that one may go all the way to the Supreme Court. It will be a big battle.

     
  • At 3/09/2008 3:34 PM, Blogger slouching mom said…

    Not to mention that if CA requires teaching certification, the very notion of homeschooling as being a different kind of education from the mainstream gets entirely subverted.

     
  • At 3/09/2008 4:52 PM, Anonymous Amy said…

    I definitely don't agree that you need a teacher's certification to be a great teacher. I think your stance actually jives well with your liberalness because it's basically just down to individual civil rights - and that's what liberals care about.

    I read about the decision in California, and I don't agree with it. I don't think a teacher's license is the answer. On one hand, I like the idea of being able to raise my kids however I want with no government interference. On the other hand, as a former teacher, I've seen home-schooling go wrong on so many, many levels. I don't think it's wrong to want some kind of system that doesn't let these kids fall through the cracks. I'm just not sure what the answer is.

    And I would never, ever, ever home school in a million years. Never. Ever.

     
  • At 3/09/2008 11:53 PM, Blogger Suzanne said…

    I'm going to go out a limb here, in which many of the fine readers of this blog may want to beat me with, and say that I have no problem with expecting home-schooling parents to demonstrate that they have teaching qualifications. As a society, we have a vested interest to make sure that all kids have access to a quality basic education. I don't care if it comes from public school, private school, parochial school, or home school, there are effective methods of learning that teachers should understand. If we expect teachers in non-home schools to meet certain standards, than it short changes home-schooled kids to exempt their teachers from those standards.

    A teaching certified parent may still determine what the child's curriculum is - somethin