This past week, someone in my mom's group asked our group for advice over e-mail about how to talk to her 7 year old daughter about a single, family friend who just had a baby. The response that resonated most with me came from a friend who speaks in terms of "usually" and "sometimes" situations. Basically that involves saying that "usually x does this, but sometimes x does that". For example, "usually girls wear earrings, but sometimes boys do too." Or in this case, "usually people are married before they have children, but sometimes unmarried people have children."
This on-line discussion led my thoughts down two paths. First, I've been reflecting on when and how to use this concept with my older son (OS) who just turned 4. Second it led me to think more and more about how to handle the difference between questions that my boys will ask me directly and issues that they may never ask directly but may arise from their articulated assumptions. This is particularly important, because many times kids don't ask the questions you think they will ask. Sometimes they absorb or respond to new situations without saying anything at all. I think that's both good and bad. It can be good because kids are accepting in a way I wistfully wish adults could be. It can be bad though when as parents we may assume that they understand more of a situation than they do in reality. Unprotected teenage sex is one of the more terrifying examples of something with serious consequences that parents desperately hope that children understand.
When I was pregnant with my younger son (YS), my husband, the Big Giraffe, and I talked with OS about the baby growing inside of me. These discussions were mostly led by OS, but there was also some direction from the Big Giraffe, and me. We sometimes even used "usually" and "sometimes" without knowing it was an official parenting communication tactic. For example, we did tell him that while I was having a c-section, babies usually come out of their mothers' vaginas. I have no idea how much of this he understood, but I figured he would just filter out whatever was over his head.
Talking about vaginas isn't ever always the most comfortable conversation, but I wanted us to have a habit of open communication fostered by dealing with issues when they arise naturally, even if he was a little young. I felt vindicated earlier this week when he brought up that conversation, because it showed me that he remembers such exchanges, even if he doesn't fully understand them.
Yesterday OS and YS were playing "house". This involved OS pretending he was the mommy, and declaring YS (who was wearing a string of mardi gras beads) to be the daddy, a My Little Pony to be the grandma, and a plastic Nemo fish to be the baby. Every once in a while the necklace would go to someone else, who would immediately become the daddy. When that happened, all the roles would switch. The mommy worked the BBQ, and the daddy cooked in the kitchen.
I had been listening to the boys play for a while, and somehow the beads and the fatherhood title kept going back to YS. I asked OS why he didn't pretend that he was a daddy. He responded that YS was already the daddy and that there could only be one daddy. I was a little taken back. In the first place, I would not expect any family which includes a My Little Pony among its ancestors and a plastic fish among its children to be bound by typical rules. In the second place, one of OS's closest friends lives with his two moms, so it never would have occurred to me that he was not used to the idea of same-sex parents.
When I asked OS why there could only be one daddy, he said that families had one mommy and one daddy. Here was my golden opportunity to have a "sometimes x, but sometimes x" conversation! I explained to him that while a lot of times families have one mommy and one daddy, sometimes families have two daddies, two mommies, or just one parent. Every family is different. We then talked about all the different families we know. When I got to his friend with two moms, there was a real "aha" moment. He knew that Carolyn and Jessica were each Jack's mommies, but he had obviously never put together that it meant that Jack has two moms. He was quite impressed by that. He talked about it for a couple of minutes. Then the My Little Pony beckoned, and he went back to the pretend family.
A. Elliot's Lesson Learned: Usually children are aware of differences around them, but sometimes they are not aware of the implications of the differences that they see.Labels: Feminism, From the Mouths of Babes, Toys / Clothes / Gear |
Wow. That is an impressive bit of parenting. Congrats to you for making that a teaching moment and for explaining it so well.
I don't know that my kids notice differences that much, or that it occurs to them that the differences are something that should be questioned. Maybe I'm fooling myself with that belief.
I do often use the "sometimes" technique, and sometimes even just say, "well, this is how we do things in our family, but other families do things their own way."